clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Fashion Critics Weigh In on Yeezy Season 3

Photo: Kevin Mazur/Getty Images

Racked is no longer publishing. Thank you to everyone who read our work over the years. The archives will remain available here; for new stories, head over to Vox.com, where our staff is covering consumer culture for The Goods by Vox. You can also see what we’re up to by signing up here.

The critics have started to weigh in on Kanye's Yeezy Season 3 extravaganza held at Madison Square Garden yesterday afternoon and the opinions on the clothes are... not great. It's not breaking any ground. But the show? In Cathy Horyn's words to Kanye: "Shut Up. Relax. You have won."

At The Washington Post, Robin Givhan was lukewarm on the clothes:

There were slim leggings and body-conscious tops, along with cropped shearlings, giant sweatshirts and skinny knit dresses. The shoes are the big sellers and there were desert boots as well as snug-fitting, booty-style heels.  And it was all shown in a warm palette of saffron, cayenne and coco. Fine. Wearable. Nice job.

But into the overall presentation:

It was frustrating not to be able to see the clothes up close. But this show was never about fabric and tailoring. And the distance — the fact that one could only see the group and not the individuals — was a reminder of how the culture sees so many of the world's disadvantaged, disaffected and downtrodden. They are not singular individuals; they are a problem, an issue, a talking point, a political football.

At Business of Fashion, Tim Blanks went easy on the clothes:

Given the scale of the venue, a conventional fashion presentation would have been lost. And also, the clothes that Kanye is making with Adidas are an evolutionary sportswear proposition. There was more colour than before, and a new graphic element that emphasised the articulation of the garments, but his formula for women remained secondskin athleticism, with oversize outerwear (desirable, that).

And pulled out more revelations from the presentation:

The kids wearing the new collection were elevated on two platforms above the hundreds of others in desert-toned clothes from older seasons, but as the hour wore on, the population on the platforms became more and more porous. They started to look like rafts, floating in a sea of people, a ragged lost tribe for whom there was no room. Above them were poised the Jenner/Kardashian klan, glittering in white shiny outfits from the Yeezy x Balmain collab, and fuzzy in huge Yeezy shearlings. There could not have been a more graphic statement about haves and have-nots in an increasingly polarised society. And it's not an image that is likely to be repeated in any other fashion show any time soon.

At The Cut, Cathy Horyn was more critical of the spectacle:

The show's problems were of a different sort, and in a way they reflect the general state of the fashion world in particular, the sense that an experience often begins with delight and almost always ends with a feeling of nothingness.

And the seating arrangements:

Note that Wintour was seated in the Kardashian section. Frankly, this was a mistake: She needed to be seated with her own people, where her power is clear and separate. Instead, she looked diminished, like a Kardashian accessory.

It's quite a different approach compared to her past reviews, where she's called out the "mind-lock" Kanye has on the fashion world and the fact that he "can't be taken seriously as a designer." Maybe Kanye really has carved out a spot for himself in fashion, and it only took a 20,000-person show-slash-album-release in Madison Square Garden to get there.