clock menu more-arrow no yes

Where to Shop on Block Island, Rhode Island

View as Map

Racked is no longer publishing. Thank you to everyone who read our work over the years. The archives will remain available here; for new stories, head over to Vox.com, where our staff is covering consumer culture for The Goods by Vox. You can also see what we’re up to by signing up here.

New Shoreham, Rhode Island — the only township on Block Island, 13 miles off Rhode Island's mainland coast — takes all the best parts of New England's better-known island destinations and leaves behind the country club vibes. Gorgeous beaches with rolling dunes and bluffs? Check. Blue hydrangea bushes and old Victorian inns? Check. Fresh fried seafood, and plenty of opportunities for souvenir shopping? Check and check.

But unlike some other seasonal locales, the shops in this down-to-earth beach town are particularly affordable — and varied. Sure, there are more than a few places to pick up fudge and taffy, or overpriced sweatshirts and cotton T-shirts proclaiming their allegiance to Block Island. But there's a whole lot more, from a vintage and thrift store chockablock with retro knick-knacks to boutiques shilling handmade jewelry, home wares, and other accessories from all over the world.

Whether you're just stopping over for a day trip from Providence or New London (which is an easy train ride from New York, by the way) or shacking up for a whole week, be sure to check out a few of our favorite shops on Block Island.

Read More

1. Blvck Market

Copy Link
17 Water St
New Shoreham, Rhode Island
(401) 282-0848
Visit Website
If you want to go home with something that reps Block Island but feels a little more fashion-forward than the regular old beach town sweatshirt, head to BLVCK Market. Owner Sean Dugan spends his winters in Bali, where the contemporary pieces from BLVCK Market’s in-house label — which includes everything from silk shorts to crochet dresses to soft men’s T-shirts — are made. The shop carries a few other laid-back, young feeling brands like RVCA and LA’s Honey Punch.
Tracy Finn

2. Glass Onion

Copy Link
241 Water St
New Shoreham, RI 02807
(401) 466-5161
Visit Website
If you’ve got enough time to visit one shop before catching your ferry, Glass Onion should be the place; you’ll definitely go home with something you love from this quirky little shop, located a stone’s throw from Block Island Ferry. There’s a nice mix of home wares, apparel, and jewelry, ranging from welcome mats made from recycled lobster trap rope to handmade local jewelry to a huge selection of striped Breton shirts and dresses from St. James.
Tracy Finn

3. The Tipsy Mermaid

Copy Link
234 Water St
New Shoreham, RI 02807
(401) 466-8822
Visit Website
Brace yourself for a lot of pastel. Tipsy Mermaid is like a Lilly Pulitzer explosion, with a huge selection of the designer’s iconic prints right up front. Walk a bit further into the shop to find several like-minded labels, all exuding a retro-preppy vibe you can get behind even if you’re not a Biff or Muffy. (If you’re really in the mood for digging through the racks, Rags across the street has a decent selection of women’s clothes, as does Tipsy Mermaid’s sister store, Bonnie & Clyde, located at 53 Water Street.)
Tracy Finn

4. East Of The River Nile Trading Company

Copy Link
459 Chapel Street
New Shoreham, RI 02807
(401) 480-9728
Visit Website
Intricate necklaces from Afghanistan, block-printed pillows from Ghana, inlaid wooden boxes from Iran, silk rugs from Turkey — East of the River Nile features cool goods from all over the globe that taken together can feel a little hippie dippie, but individually can be styled into any wardrobe or lifestyle to great effect. The extensive (and inexpensive) jewelry selection is a good place to start.
Tracy Finn

5. Red Right Return

Copy Link
Dodge St
New Shoreham, RI 02807
Straddling the line between vintage, thrift, and antique store, Red Right Return is the place for truly one-of-a-kind finds on Block island. Deadstock 1950s denim, estate jewelry (including amazing cocktail rings), and vintage glassware were some of the highlights during our last visit, but the selection is always changing. Check out the shop’s annex across the street for bigger items like furniture.
Tracy Finn

6. Lazy Fish

Copy Link
235 Dodge St
New Shoreham, RI 02807
(401) 497-3526
This large, somewhat rambling space is full of homewares, local art, jewelry, and apparel (including vintage) sourced from near and far. Owner Carolyn Collins was formerly an interior designer, and her wonderful eye is evident throughout the shop’s artful displays. And if all that shopping has made you hungry, now is a good time to stop by the adorable Persephone Kitchen for a coffee or draft kombucha and homemade snack next door.
Tracy Finn

7. Marmar Jewels

Copy Link
64 Dodge St
New Shoreham, RI 02807
(215) 880-3922
Visit Website
Run by jewelry designer Martha Andrew, Mar Mar features a rotating display of indie jewelers from around the country in addition to Andrew’s own designs (check out the schedule of trunk shows during your visit for the chance to meet one of them in person). The selection includes lots of organic shapes and rough-cut semi-precious stones; prices start around $50.
Tracy Finn

8. Diamondblue Surf Shop

Copy Link
442 Dodge St
New Shoreham, RI 02807
(401) 466-3145
Visit Website
Unsurprisingly, there are plenty of places to shop for swimwear on the island. Diamondblue Surf Shop has the best selection. Browse suits and apparel by surf brands like Roxy, Rip Curl, and Hurley as well as lesser-known swim labels like IMSY.
Tracy Finn

1. Blvck Market

17 Water St, New Shoreham, Rhode Island
Tracy Finn
If you want to go home with something that reps Block Island but feels a little more fashion-forward than the regular old beach town sweatshirt, head to BLVCK Market. Owner Sean Dugan spends his winters in Bali, where the contemporary pieces from BLVCK Market’s in-house label — which includes everything from silk shorts to crochet dresses to soft men’s T-shirts — are made. The shop carries a few other laid-back, young feeling brands like RVCA and LA’s Honey Punch.
17 Water St
New Shoreham, Rhode Island

2. Glass Onion

241 Water St, New Shoreham, RI 02807
Tracy Finn
If you’ve got enough time to visit one shop before catching your ferry, Glass Onion should be the place; you’ll definitely go home with something you love from this quirky little shop, located a stone’s throw from Block Island Ferry. There’s a nice mix of home wares, apparel, and jewelry, ranging from welcome mats made from recycled lobster trap rope to handmade local jewelry to a huge selection of striped Breton shirts and dresses from St. James.
241 Water St
New Shoreham, RI 02807

3. The Tipsy Mermaid

234 Water St, New Shoreham, RI 02807
Tracy Finn
Brace yourself for a lot of pastel. Tipsy Mermaid is like a Lilly Pulitzer explosion, with a huge selection of the designer’s iconic prints right up front. Walk a bit further into the shop to find several like-minded labels, all exuding a retro-preppy vibe you can get behind even if you’re not a Biff or Muffy. (If you’re really in the mood for digging through the racks, Rags across the street has a decent selection of women’s clothes, as does Tipsy Mermaid’s sister store, Bonnie & Clyde, located at 53 Water Street.)
234 Water St
New Shoreham, RI 02807

4. East Of The River Nile Trading Company

459 Chapel Street, New Shoreham, RI 02807
Tracy Finn
Intricate necklaces from Afghanistan, block-printed pillows from Ghana, inlaid wooden boxes from Iran, silk rugs from Turkey — East of the River Nile features cool goods from all over the globe that taken together can feel a little hippie dippie, but individually can be styled into any wardrobe or lifestyle to great effect. The extensive (and inexpensive) jewelry selection is a good place to start.
459 Chapel Street
New Shoreham, RI 02807

5. Red Right Return

Dodge St, New Shoreham, RI 02807
Tracy Finn
Straddling the line between vintage, thrift, and antique store, Red Right Return is the place for truly one-of-a-kind finds on Block island. Deadstock 1950s denim, estate jewelry (including amazing cocktail rings), and vintage glassware were some of the highlights during our last visit, but the selection is always changing. Check out the shop’s annex across the street for bigger items like furniture.
Dodge St
New Shoreham, RI 02807

6. Lazy Fish

235 Dodge St, New Shoreham, RI 02807
Tracy Finn
This large, somewhat rambling space is full of homewares, local art, jewelry, and apparel (including vintage) sourced from near and far. Owner Carolyn Collins was formerly an interior designer, and her wonderful eye is evident throughout the shop’s artful displays. And if all that shopping has made you hungry, now is a good time to stop by the adorable Persephone Kitchen for a coffee or draft kombucha and homemade snack next door.
235 Dodge St
New Shoreham, RI 02807

7. Marmar Jewels

64 Dodge St, New Shoreham, RI 02807
Tracy Finn
Run by jewelry designer Martha Andrew, Mar Mar features a rotating display of indie jewelers from around the country in addition to Andrew’s own designs (check out the schedule of trunk shows during your visit for the chance to meet one of them in person). The selection includes lots of organic shapes and rough-cut semi-precious stones; prices start around $50.
64 Dodge St
New Shoreham, RI 02807

8. Diamondblue Surf Shop

442 Dodge St, New Shoreham, RI 02807
Tracy Finn
Unsurprisingly, there are plenty of places to shop for swimwear on the island. Diamondblue Surf Shop has the best selection. Browse suits and apparel by surf brands like Roxy, Rip Curl, and Hurley as well as lesser-known swim labels like IMSY.
442 Dodge St
New Shoreham, RI 02807